Montauk Distilling Bellamy Spiced Rum

Bellamy showcases a complex blend of vanilla bean, allspice, and citrus. A double-gold winner and one of the anchors of the Montauk Distilling rum range, alongside Black Sail aged rum, the Sunburn cinnamon expression, and a 117-proof navy strength. Bellamy is the big-flavored one — spice-forward and built for mixing rather than contemplation, named in the buccaneer register the whole label leans into.

Cocktail suggestion: The distillery's own suggestion is three ounces with pineapple juice, which tells you exactly what it's for: rum punch, a dark and stormy with real ginger beer, or spiked cider once the weather turns.